Spinach and Easter Grass: Reviewing a First Friday Q&A

In last month’s First Friday Q&A, I talked about why top quality preschool is so beneficial, with the caution that hanging a roof shingles that claims PRESCHOOL and congregating with children, is insufficient to qualify for the advantages early education has actually received recognized researches.

I made use of a pie example– delicious chocolate pie as well as mud pie are both called “pie”, yet there’s absolutely a huge distinction between them.

Well, I have actually discovered a much better analogy. And it comes with a research study that appears to confirm simply what I was talking about.

A current write-up from NPR described the disturbing searching for in a research out of Vanderbilt University, revealing that while participants in the state’s PreK program revealed significant benefits at the beginning of kindergarten, those advantages disappeared by the end of preschool, and as a matter of fact, by 2nd quality the youngsters began to underperform when compared to their peers that had not gotten state PreK services.


You ‘d need to believe that’s precisely what the state’s federal government authorities were asking, after putting $86 million a year into their state program.

Some onlookers have actually fasted to leap to the conclusion that preschool doesn’t actually issue. The state is losing their money.

While the last assertion is something I make sure Tennessee will be analyzing, the previous is hard to suggest. As I stated in the First Friday video, as policy-makers have actually priced quote, and also as the NPR post mentioned, there are several research studies that corroborate the valuable influence of quality very early education and learning.

However the devil is in the details. And it’s the word “quality” that makes all the distinction. You can’t change the formula and expect the same end result.

It appears that’s highly likely what took place in Tennessee. According to the study’s author, Dale Farran, her outcomes are not a condemnation of preschool all at once, but maybe a sign that the PreK program that has actually been carried out doesn’t have all the appropriate active ingredients.

Actually, the NPR write-up mentions the man Tennessee worked with to assist develop standards for their program, Steven Barnett, director of the National Institute for Early Education Research, when it states, ” Tennessee’s program looks excellent on paper however … the state made a couple of key blunders when it scaled the program as much as more than 900 classrooms throughout 95 counties. Initially, it created no system for quality assurance to make certain instructors were following best methods from one end of the state to the various other. Additionally, Barnett says, the state underfunded the program.” (NPR)

( And right here’s where the oh-so-much-better metaphor comes in.)

Farran reacted, claiming this undercutting may be the source of the problem. “It’s like claiming spinach is actually great for you, yet we can not pay for spinach. But below, I have actually obtained this Easter lawn. Perhaps that will be just as excellent.” (NPR)

Fantastic metaphor, right?

Quality early childhood years education offers terrific advantages for kids. But strip that high quality experience of all its nutrients as well as it matters not what you call it or what you invested in it, it will not have the same influence.

Read the complete NPR short article below.

Locate NAEYC’s reaction here.

Leading image by Robert Gourley.

Leave a Reply